Wednesday, April 29, 2009

In God's Country

I write this fable as a cautionary tale for America:

Drawn by the opportunity for jobs and greater freedoms and to escape hunger and oppression, Mexican citizens began to immigrate into the border areas of America. The numbers of the immigrants was small enough that it did not seem to threaten the American economy or culture. Even though they had no legal right to enter, there were enough jobs, money, food and space to accommodate the arrivers, so the Americans tentatively welcomed them. Some groups of Americans even welcomed their new Mexican neighbors with open arms.

Many Americans, and even the government leaders, shared personal and government resources, made personal friends with many of the immigrants and learned about their culture. As the Mexican population grew, people and the government sold the Mexican community property, provided education and health care resources to the immigrants. Under the care, support and mutually beneficial relationships with the Americans, the Mexican-American population began to thrive.

New immigrants joined the thriving population at a steady pace and the Mexican population began to form larger and larger communities of their own, making their relationship with the local governments and other original inhabitants less and less necessary. Unlike the first immigrants, the newer arrivals did not have to mingle as much with the Americans. Relations between the cultures weakened over time as the newest immigrants made no effort to learn English, transplanted as much of their culture from Mexico as possible, and even did business as much as possible within their own community.

After years of steady immigration and a generation that was born on this American soil, the Mexican-American population had grown so large that they began to view the land as theirs. As their needs increased, they became more aggressive about taking the resources they could see around them. When necessary, they even used violence or intimidation. It seemed they no longer feared (or respected) the Americans.

The episodes of violence increased at an alarming rate. The American population grew restless with these now-violent interlopers who were consuming more and more resources. Out of fear and retribution, the Americans launched a military offensive against the Mexican-American population and the war was on.

In a shocking turn, the Mexican-American population was much stronger than expected and heavily armed. In one stunning and violently grotesque episode, the Mexicans attacked the Texas government and (as crazy as this sounds) beheaded the governor of Texas and posted his head on a stake in the Texas capitol. Not through, and fully aroused in their anger, the Mexicans captured the 9-year old son of that governor, shipped him south and enslaved him…

I’ll end the story now but the next few chapters only get worse. The Mexicans eventually take completely over America through alternating bouts of political trickery and literal slaughter. By the time the story ends, the original Americans make up less than 2% of the total population.

Oh, one last thing, this story is true. Just insert "Christian Europeans" everywhere you see Mexican or Mexican-American above and it’s a sketch of the annihilation that unchecked immigration brought upon the Native Americans in the 1600s, right down to the beheading, slavery and slaughter. In the later chapters, more generations of American immigrants continue the torture and mass murder, including women and children, that would make the Taliban jealous. Even if you think you know the stories, it might be a good idea to revisit the history, especially in light of the intensifying immigration reform discussion in America.

6 comments:

Erick said...

Can't tell exactly where you are going here. You could be discussing the perils of unchecked immigration. I bet the Native American's wished they had built a big wall and kept the European Christians out. Maybe they wish they hadn't helped that first Thanksgiving and simply let them die off. Do you think we should learn from this history and limit (or eliminate) immigration?

Or you could be making a comment on White, Christian America's hypocrisy. The ruthlessness and disregard with which the Native Americans were treated is ??? (I don't really know the word because I was going to say unfathomable, but then you see how we have recently treated suspected "terrorists" and it becomes fathomable). In any event the callousness with which the European settlers treated the Native Americans is not a celebrated part of American History. I don't recall learning exactly what happened. It seems it was along the lines of the following: "After years of battles (unprovoked by the settlers) the American government conceded that the Native Americans should have their own land and gave up Oklahoma and relocated the Native Americans there at great cost to the US." Nevermind the forced removal from lands, including sacred lands; the countless deaths (which even when those are discussed they are romanticized"Trail of Tears"); and the reason they got Oklahoma was because it was thought to be worthless (until oil/natural gas was discovered and then watch out the US wants its land back).

I'm going to guess you were doing the latter option. In which case I agree with what you are saying without saying. I'm glad I'm an American and glad I live here. However, I don't think I'm so blinded by such pride as to think our poop doesn't stink and that we've done everything right. It's when we (the royal we as in country) think we are better and ignore the injustices and cruelties we and our forefathers undertook that I think we lose face and credibility in the world. We've screwed up just as much as everyone else, why do we get to dictate to the world how things should be done? We should be a part of the discussion, but not the dictator in the room, just an active participant.

Unknown said...

I think that EC is right, Mr bang was pointing out the hypocrisy of white america.
I have been pondering this for some time. While watching a documentary on extinct languages, a native american said something to the effect of, "how can a country claim to be morally superior when it is built on bloodshed, genocide, and ethnic cleansing" of the highest order. We have done the same thing generation after generation to people after people. We enslaved africans, destroyed indigenous cultures, imprisoned immigrants, and continue oppressing minorities. When we realize that we, as americans, are no better than every other human on the planet we will be able to make progress toward an equitable world.

Anonymous said...

As Obama would say "don't blame me for what happened when I was three months old."

DVD said...

I will assume Anon is just being funny, but it gets to a serious point that warrants unpacking: what do we do, if anything, because of this history?

Through humor, I think Anon brings up a common response: hey, it wasn't me, so why should I care?

This feels similar to the response of "I didn't pay the worker substandard wages and put them in inhumane conditions, I just bought the shirt she made."

There's a definite continuum here, though, because if I sit on land that was stolen from its original inhabitants, so does that mean I have to give it back?

Very interesting dilemma. What is our response to the facts of our brutal history?

Erick said...

there was an interesting article in the Dailymail a few days ago about a EU Court ruling saying that current owners of land in Cyprus had to give it back to the original owner that lost possession only because they fled persecution. A very interesting reading. I can't put my hands on the link right now but I'm sure if you google Cyprus, Briton, and land you'll find it fairly quickly.

Thoughts42Day said...

Anon brings up a good point - one I have heard used for a variety of atrocities that were committed before my time. Although I have found this truth to be helpful and healing in dealing with the emotion of shame that I often feel as a white American - I think it does little for the cause of change. The questions : Who's responsible? and What are we going to do about it? are very different. I grieve for the destructive methods used in creating this country, and celebrate the honorable ones - knowing that both still continue today. The truth deserves to be told though - enough of America pointing out the genocide and destruction of other countries without owning up to our own.