The next morning, I realize that the most remarkable thing about his speech last night was that immediately after it ended people were discussing its content, its delivery and whether or not this speech helped Barack in this election. Why is that remarkable? This was a black candidate. I cannot do this topic justice, but how about just a pause to comprehend, a deep breath that we let out slowly in deep satisfaction that we are here. In Barack's own lifetime, we have gone from dehumanizing segregation, criminal denial of voting rights and rank prejudice to the actual possibility that a black man will be elected President. Sigh.
Back to the convention speech. I like eloquence, oration, inspiration. This one was not in the same vein as his masterpieces like the Keynote Address of 2004, his speech on religion and politics in 2006, his victory speech in Iowa, his Yes We Can speech in New Hampshire or the Unity speech in Philadelphia. For that, I was disappointed. But I accept the reality that not every voter thinks like me. I read the texts of those speeches and think "I want someone who thinks like that as President." I think Barack's convention speech was aimed far more at the "rest" of the people. For that, the speech was nearly perfect.
I had one serious problem. It was the only distortion I heard, but Barack did say that McCain defined middle class as anyone making less than 5 million dollars a year. I heard the Q&A giving rise to that distortion and while McCain gave a poor answer, that is not what McCain said. McCain has said and done enough to justify accusations that he doesn't know or doesn't get the middle class (as Barack said elsewhere in his speech), but it was a pure distortion to use the 5 million dollars statement like that.
On economic issues, energy issues and education I believe Barack laid out a direction that will resonate with the majority of voters. On social issues of abortion, guns and gay marriage, I believe Barack sought common ground but I'm sure there will be many for whom these issues are all-or-nothing. Health care seemed to me the only traditionally liberal issue laid out by Barack, but in my opinion that is an idea whose time has come.
The best political points of the night were turning McCain's "celebrity" attack against Barack on its head. Well executed and true. And seizing the McCain campaign slogan and deftly exposing its implication.
At least Barack threw me a bone at the end.
This country of ours has more wealth than any nation, but that's not what makes us rich. We have the most powerful military on Earth, but that's not what makes us strong. Our universities and our culture are the envy of the world, but that's not what keeps the world coming to our shores.
Instead, it is that American spirit - that American promise - that pushes us forward even when the path is uncertain; that binds us together in spite of our differences; that makes us fix our eye not on what is seen, but what is unseen, that better place around the bend.
That promise is our greatest inheritance. It's a promise I make to my daughters when I tuck them in at night, and a promise that you make to yours - a promise that has led immigrants to cross oceans and pioneers to travel west; a promise that led workers to picket lines, and women to reach for the ballot.
And it is that promise that forty five years ago today, brought Americans from every corner of this land to stand together on a Mall in Washington, before Lincoln's Memorial, and hear a young preacher from Georgia speak of his dream.
The men and women who gathered there could've heard many things. They could've heard words of anger and discord. They could've been told to succumb to the fear and frustration of so many dreams deferred.
But what the people heard instead - people of every creed and color, from every walk of life - is that in America, our destiny is inextricably linked. That together, our dreams can be one.
"We cannot walk alone," the preacher cried. "And as we walk, we must make the pledge that we shall always march ahead. We cannot turn back."
America, we cannot turn back. Not with so much work to be done. Not with so many children to educate, and so many veterans to care for. Not with an economy to fix and cities to rebuild and farms to save. Not with so many families to protect and so many lives to mend. America, we cannot turn back. We cannot walk alone. At this moment, in this election, we must pledge once more to march into the future. Let us keep that promise - that American promise - and in the words of Scripture hold firmly, without wavering, to the hope that we confess.
10 comments:
I agree with your assessment. However, I was very pleased with the speech. It was by far his best "political" speech. He didn't pull punches or make his point with nuanced statement. He called out the GOP and McCain directly. Yes he distorted the statement, but come on, that statement deserved to be distorted. In no context describing or answering a question should the words $5 M and middle class be used together.
Last night in his speech he took a lot of the fire power away from the Republicans. He didn't look like a crazy liberal or a tax and spend liberal. He looked like a person trying to help out the common man, help that man keep his house, his job, his family.
That will tough to beat come November, because in November 100,000,000 common men and women will be deciding; not the political pundits and Washington insiders.
I've always thought "Yes, he can". He has the charisma and message to deliver on that. The question to ask is, should he? Being a typical American who doesn't have the time or desire to make the time to read the text of all his speeches and try to decipher all of the contexts and inuendos (ignore this run-on) I find myself going with my "gut" and my "gut" won't let me trust him yet. Now, I'm not saying I trust McCain, either. However, the Alaska governor throws another aspect to McCain for me that I'll have to piece together.
When the speech was over, I had a similar reaction. I thought he did what he needed to do to make his case. This time, he had allowed others to inspire while he made the practical case. I was glad to see that he could do it.
I, too, was very disappointed in the comment about $5 million. It just felt pointless and like he would expect us not to know the truth of the context. I like to be given more credit.
However, I felt more confident at the end of the speech than I did at the beginning that he is capable of delivering on his promises of hope and change. I still have a few misgivings, but not in his leadership, per se.
I am looking forward to the next convention and hearing the case for McCain. They definitely have a harder assignment to make the case to me, but my mind is definitely not made up.
I am ashamed to say I haven't listened to a whole Barry speech. I have heard enough to realize that he has no respect for life and not have any trust in him at all. I don't understand why so many are lured by this man and have been a little disappointed with many of my friends and people of my generation. I think he is just what America is looking for and I am glad my future is secure.
Nice to have you join us, though sad it was to call all Barack supporters naive, stupid or evil. That's a lot of people, Carrie.
But I look forward to your support for your very bold statement "he has no respect for life." Anyone with no respect for life should not be President; heck, shouldn't be allowed to walk the streets! So if you care to, please elaborate on your very serious accusation.
DVD, I don't think I called any Barry supporters "naive, stupid or evil." In fact the people I know that will vote for him are much smarter than I am and not evil. I said "I don't understand."
Why do I say "no respect for life?" Well, I work in a pro-life job and someone who supports late-term abortions, in my opinion, has no respect for life. I know that abortion is a choice women have, but I have a problem with it. I won't began that discussion here, but maybe we can talk about it sometime.
As I said, I haven't heard many of his speeches, but what I have heard I just don't understand. We have different ways of thinking. I listened to him speak on abortion once and he said things like the pro-life and pro-choice people can agree and then said something about giving women the same rights as men. I just don't see how these issues compare.
I have also read some of his view on euthanasia, and I don't agree with that either. I worry about someone who thinks that the choice of life or death is in their hands.
If you believe, as you re-stated, that Barack Obama has NO respect for life, then you inherently believe his supporters MUST be naive, stupid or evil. You can't pretend otherwise.
I disagree wth Barack on most abortion issues, but I have the honesty to admit he cares about life as much as I do - we just disagree about when it starts. Like you, I even have a hard tme understanding why a caring person wouldn't err on the side of life. But I also have a really hard time understanding why a pro-life person is willing to execute an adult, but that doesn't mean they have no respect for life.
I am going to weigh in on this discussion. Why? I have no idea. I have done a lot of research on both candidates, and I am going to do a lot more before I cast my vote in November. I have found little to be concerned about when it comes to Obama's stance on euthanasia. Perhaps I'm missing something there.
As to abortion, I am troubled by Obama's stance on late-term partial birth abortions. I cannot know for sure, but I don't think it necessarily reflects a lack of respect for human life on his part. Rather, he seems to err on the side of protection of doctors and mothers rather than erring on the side of protecting a potential life. While I certainly don't agree with it, partial birth abortions account for fewer than two percent of abortions out there and will not be the single issue for which I'll cast my vote.
I know that your profession brings with it a very different perspective and sensitivity. I could not do what you do every day and go home without feeling a sense of loss each time a mother chooses abortion. However, since I don't believe Roe v. Wade will ever be repealed, I am not going to vote with that hope in mind.
I have an honest question as to what respect for human life means.
Does that mean only respect for unborn infants?
What about Senator McCain's pro-death penalty stance (I believe that is a true statement)? I don't think the government's killing of a human (for any reason) respects human life. Thus, can we say he has no respect for human life?
What about the lack of a response by the current administration to the Darfur Crisis? Those are innocent individuals suffering. The lack of response to the African American communities' needs post Katrina? The lack of a concerted effort to change China's human rights violations? All these failures seem to show a disrespect for human life.
In my opinion, the issue of respect for human life is a complex issue and cannot be deciphered by a person's stance on a single issue, nor can it be honestly stated that the GOP has the corner on the market of respect for human life and the DEMs are anti-life.
I'm concerned (maybe a little offended) when Obama supporters are described as "lured" or "fooled" by Obama's smooth talkin' jive.
I still have some additional work and soul-searching to do before I make a final voting decision, but the message of Hope has had a significant impact on me this campaign season. Though I may disagree with some of Obama's policies, when I'm asked to choose a President, policy is not the #1 factor for me. The candidate who perfectly reflects all my beliefs is not running for president. He is a Traffic Engineer in Jefferson City who wants a primary seat belt law, thinks video games get the blame poor parenting deserves, and loves apple pie with Cool Whip. My voting tends to focus more on my perception of the candidate's leadership skill and playing well with others.
What I love about this process, though, is that we each get to choose how we choose. If you'd like to pick your President, Governor, Mayor, and School Board based on their Immigration stance, you get to. If you want all females or all African-Americans or all Skater Dudes running the country, you get to choose that, too. I tend to lean toward Leadership and the ability to get things done - and I'm OK if others decide based on other criteria.
Post a Comment